Book Review of Going Public Why Baptism Is Required for Church Membership

• Dwelling house
• My Books

Open Preview

Meet a Problem?

We'd love your assistance. Let usa know what'due south incorrect with this preview of Going Public by Bobby Jamieson.

Thanks for telling us most the trouble.

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign upwardly.

Community Reviews

 · 132 ratings  · 28 reviews

Start your review of Going Public: Why Baptism Is Required for Church building Membership

October 09, 2017 Ronni Kurtz rated it really liked it

Jamieson'south volume is seriously helpful on a relatively difficult topic for a number of reasons. (1) He writes in a fashion that is a model for how serious theology can be accessable to any motivated reader. He writes on items equally hard as Greek syntax, hermeneutics, covenant and kingdom theology, ecclesiology, and more while never feeling inaccessible. (ii) He is a step alee of his readers. There were multiple times when I was reading through Jamieson's work where I thought of an excpession to what Jamieson's book is seriously helpful on a relatively difficult topic for a number of reasons. (1) He writes in a way that is a model for how serious theology can be accessable to whatsoever motivated reader. He writes on items every bit difficult as Greek syntax, hermeneutics, covenant and kingdom theology, ecclesiology, and more than while never feeling inaccessible. (ii) He is a step ahead of his readers. In that location were multiple times when I was reading through Jamieson'southward work where I thought of an excpession to whatever event he was covering. Still, he almost always got to what ever outcome I had in heed. (3) He gave categories for problems that were unresolved for me. While I don't concur with all of Jamieson'due south conclusions, or better said that I nonetheless have questions regarding some of his conclusions, he provided theological categories for me throughout the book that volition be helpful as long every bit I am conversant in ecclesiology. (iv) Perhaps the most helpful thing in this entire work is Jamieson's footnotes. If you are interested in how the ordinances interplay with i another and how they relate to membership - the footnotes and bibliography throughout this piece of work will prove to be a treasure trove to you. He pointed me towards multiple works I was unfamiliar with that aided in my thought process regarding this consequence.

I do, however, have a few remaining unasnwered questions and plant myself thinking that he was overplaying a few of his small points. Too, the title and sub-title of the volume aren't super helpful. The work is much more than the human action of "going public" and information technology tackles more than than merely demonstrating theological arguments for why credobaptism should be a requirment for church membership.

This volition be a work a recommend to any thinking through this important issue and one that I will refer dorsum to on occasion.

(Pardon typos, I wrote this on a phone)

...more than

Oct 21, 2019 Marc Sims rated it it was astonishing

This is a deceptive book. It looks like a popular level, "questions pastors take" kind of book, but hidden within its slim 220 pages is a dense theological argument virtually baptism, the Lord'southward Supper, and membership in the church. Bobby makes a detailed argument from the nature of the covenants, the kingdom of God, and authority given to the church to contend for an "ecclesial shape" to the ordinances. I went into this volume questioning the relationship betwixt the ordinances and church building membership an This is a deceptive book. It looks like a popular level, "questions pastors have" kind of volume, merely subconscious within its slim 220 pages is a dense theological argument about baptism, the Lord's Supper, and membership in the church. Bobby makes a detailed argument from the nature of the covenants, the kingdom of God, and say-so given to the church to argue for an "ecclesial shape" to the ordinances. I went into this book questioning the relationship between the ordinances and church membership and was profoundly helped. ...more

May 28, 2020 Jeremy Mueller rated it actually liked it

A robust and biblical theology of Baptism. "Without Baptism, there may be a self-proclaimed kingdom person, only there is no kingdom people" (95). God desires kingdom people to comprise his church building (Matt. 16:18) and baptism is the means by which he has given us to publicly identify these people! Baptism binds one to many, as Bobby argues in this volume. I promise you lot'll check this book out to raise your agreement of Baptism and its blueprint for the believer and for the church. A robust and biblical theology of Baptism. "Without Baptism, there may be a cocky-proclaimed kingdom person, but there is no kingdom people" (95). God desires kingdom people to comprise his church (Matt. 16:xviii) and baptism is the means past which he has given u.s. to publicly identify these people! Baptism binds ane to many, as Bobby argues in this book. I hope you'll bank check this volume out to enhance your understanding of Baptism and its blueprint for the believer and for the church. ...more

November 20, 2018 Mark Donald rated it actually liked it

A comprehensive defense for uniting Baptism, Church Membership, and the Lord's Supper. Helpful for someone who'southward wrestling with what baptism is and how it functions in the life of a Christian and the church. Recommended.

Sep 25, 2020 Trent Thompson rated information technology really liked it

Helpful book on why baptism is (or ought to be) a prerequisite for church membership. The volume is simultaneously accessible yet dense. I'd recommend this to anyone wanting to call back deeper about baptism and its function inside the life of a local church building.

BOOK REVIEW: Going Public:Why Baptism is Required for Church Membership by Bobby Jamieson
Today it seems anybody is "going public" virtually something in their lives, whether information technology is that they are in a relationship, getting married, are getting divorced, are "coming out" about their sexuality, are angry virtually some injustice and a whole host of other things. Writer Bobby Jamieson has written a book about "going public" regarding the most important, significant event that can have place in anyone's life BOOK REVIEW: Going Public:Why Baptism is Required for Church Membership by Bobby Jamieson
Today information technology seems everyone is "going public" nearly something in their lives, whether information technology is that they are in a relationship, getting married, are getting divorced, are "coming out" about their sexuality, are angry about some injustice and a whole host of other things. Author Bobby Jamieson has written a volume about "going public" regarding the most important, significant event that can take identify in anyone'southward life...and that is condign a follower of Jesus Christ and what that means AND what happens promptly after a person believes in Christ. The author answers the important question, "Does everyone who joins a local church demand to be baptized?" The author and I both believe YES!
Going Public is a book about baptism and why the author, and I, believe baptism "is required for church membership." In his book he emphasizes the absolute importance of baptism for the believer, for the church equally well as for the watching earth of people. The author stresses in his book that baptism by immersion is an essential for church membership. His bulletin is clear, piece of cake to be understood and essential to be followed equally what he writes is clearly Biblical.
"Baptism is where faith goes public" is what author Jamieson writes. Amen. He believes that upon salvation the new believer should exist baptized as before long as is humanly possible for the believer to evidence his "identification with Jesus Christ and His people." He shares other reasons why baptism is important as well.
In Going Public you will read and understand the different views apropos baptism such equally "paedobaptism" or "infant baptism" or sprinkling and baptism by immersion of a confirmed believer in Jesus Christ. The author is gracious towards those who believe in "infant baptism" and practices information technology; even so, his position according to the Give-and-take of God is that it is not Biblical and even early church history bears that out. The book is theological, historical and soundly Biblical in its treatment of the subject field. And he fully understands and expounds on the idea of tradition versus what is Biblical concerning the matter of Baptism. He shares how historically and traditionally the act of baptism and how information technology is done as well every bit the timing of it and its significance to the laic, the church and the world has inverse. And it HAS changed and not for the better as far every bit I am personally concerned.
In "Going Public" author Jamieson also shares the Biblical perspective apropos the Lord's Table. As with the event of Baptism, he reveals the historical and traditional views of Communion and how the church views and performs communion today versus how the early church practiced information technology. And just equally with baptism he explains at that place is a major difference between how communion was proficient, such equally how often it was done, in the early on church building and in the church today.
If you lot desire to know and understand how the Apostles and the early church building fathers taught well-nigh and expert Baptism and Communion, using the Discussion of God equally the guide, this book is a must read for you. It should clear up whatever misconceptions you have regarding Baptism and Communion too as answer whatsoever questions you might take regarding both practices from a Biblical perspective. I highly recommend this book. To larn more about this book or purchase a re-create for yourself visit the B&H Publishers Website: http://www.bhpublishinggroup.com/prod...
Disclosure of Fabric Connection: I received this book free from the author and 9Marks to read and review. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my ain. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission'due south sixteen CFR, Function 255: "Guides Apropos the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Ad."
#GoingPublic #Baptism #BobbyJamieson #9Marks #BAndHPublishers #TheChurch #Communion #ChurchMembership #InfantBaptism #BaptismByImmersion ...more

May 21, 2020 Noah Nevils rated information technology really liked information technology

This would be a v star review considering of the nifty arguments, backed by learning and charity, found in this book, simply information technology could have been a hundred pages or so shorter. Jamieson felt the need to recapitulate everything he said in the bodies of his chapters at the end of each, and opened most sections with padding every bit well. This plagues Christian writing.

I highly recommend this volume to all Christians, just particularly Baptist ones.

Apr 26, 2018 Kevin Choate rated information technology it was astonishing

In a few short words, this book is the Baptist Ecclesiology Handbook - membership matters, baptism is a profession of an inward alter, and baptism is the means in which God'due south people are grafted into the Church building.

Very systematic approach to Baptism and it's importance to church membership.

Jun 07, 2018 Marc Minter rated it it was amazing

I found this volume to exist a likable, direct argument for laic'south baptism every bit the theological and public signal of someone becoming a Christian. Jamieson's repeated obeisance to Paedobaptist comrades throughout the volume makes him hard to disregard as a rabid sectarian of sorts. He but and amiably asserts the biblical explanation and defense for believer's baptism. He so works through the logical implications of this doctrine is such as way so as to present laic's baptism as essential to I institute this book to exist a likable, direct argument for believer's baptism as the theological and public signal of someone condign a Christian. Jamieson's repeated obeisance to Paedobaptist comrades throughout the book makes him difficult to disregard as a rabid sectarian of sorts. He just and amiably asserts the biblical caption and defense for laic'south baptism. He then works through the logical implications of this doctrine is such equally way so as to present believer's baptism equally essential to the structure of church membership.

Quoting Robert Stein, Jamieson describes "faith going public" past pointing to v "integrally related components" of conversion. "Repentance, faith, and confession by the individual, regeneration… and baptism by representatives of the Christian community." This last phrase carries quite a bit of freight, but this is the basic idea Jamieson explicates throughout the book. Baptism is integrally related to conversion (necessarily mail service-dating punctiliar conversion and serving equally the public adjuration-sign), information technology is the affidavit of Christian representatives, and information technology is normally carried out in the context of formal Christian communities (i.due east. local churches). Jamieson's book attempts (I retrieve successfully so) to unpack this freight and examine the substance of it.

Honestly, I found this book to be a refreshing joint of what I have been trying to practice among my own church family. Information technology is hard to interact very critically with information technology. I idea Jamieson did a expert job of laying out his case, and I believe that he also stayed within the boundaries of Scripture and suitable deductions from the diligent and faithful written report of information technology. I also thought that Jamieson'southward book would be quite accessible to the unstudied Christian. I think most Christians would be able to sympathize the overall argument of this volume, and I think the bite-sized chapters and sections would non exist too difficult to swallow and digest.

If I might brand one negative comment most this volume, it would be related to the compliment I gave it above. While the chapters and sections were arranged in a simple and like shooting fish in a barrel-to-follow fashion, I remember there was a little too much redundant content. Each chapter began by "putting his cards on the table" with lengthy introductions that essentially presented the chapter'due south content in brief. Jamieson offered the reader an selection to omit an entire chapter so as to avoid likewise much repetition, but I wonder if this doesn't merely make my point that the re-packaged content could have simply been left out entirely.

Overall, I think this book was great. I even programme to procure "Where religion Goes Public" (chapter 3) and "Turning the Tables" (affiliate ten) as independent papers to distribute amid my congregation. These capacity are especially helpful in laying out the basic theology of what believer's baptism is and why is it necessary for church membership.

...more

February xvi, 2019 Todd Bryant rated it actually liked information technology

This is probably the almost thorough treatment of baptism (and perhaps even the Lord's Supper) that I've ever read. This volume is actually written to answer the question as to whether churches should allow unbaptized people that profess faith in Jesus to be members. This is often proficient when a church allows paedobaptist baptism equally sufficient. Jamieson does a stellar job at showing the necessity of baptism for membership. This is far, far more than a proof-texting effort. His word is thoro This is probably the nigh thorough treatment of baptism (and perhaps even the Lord'southward Supper) that I've ever read. This book is actually written to reply the question as to whether churches should let unbaptized people that profess religion in Jesus to be members. This is often practiced when a church building allows paedobaptist baptism as sufficient. Jamieson does a stellar chore at showing the necessity of baptism for membership. This is far, far more than a proof-texting attempt. His word is thorough - Biblically thorough.

I recollect he also did a fine job at connecting baptism (and the Lord's Supper) to the operation of the keys of the kingdom by the church. This is a rarely discussed truth in our mean solar day - nevertheless a clear didactics by Jesus. Understanding this one point will improve a church building's arroyo to the ordinances.

Though Jamieson and myself would differ in a couple of places on the awarding of the truths in this book, I was greatly challenged and encouraged past Going Public. I'd certainly recommend it, especially to church leaders.

...more

Jul 07, 2018 Craig rated it really liked it

In this book, Jamieson argues that believer's baptism ought to be required for membership in a church. He is specifically going subsequently the practice of allowing paedobaptists to be members in a credobaptist church without undergoing believer's baptism. He makes a good argument which would exist difficult to summarize in this cursory synopsis. Basically, he argues that credobaptists believe that believer's baptism is a command of Christ; therefore it should be required for church membership, particularly In this book, Jamieson argues that believer's baptism ought to be required for membership in a church. He is specifically going later on the practise of allowing paedobaptists to be members in a credobaptist church without undergoing believer's baptism. He makes a proficient argument which would exist difficult to summarize in this brief synopsis. Basically, he argues that credobaptists believe that believer's baptism is a control of Christ; therefore it should be required for church membership, especially since baptism is a public testimony to having been bought past Christ and congenital into his church. If anything, this book is too thorough, oft overlapping itself with arguments already made: but I'd prefer that to an statement that is as well thin! ...more than

Jul 05, 2020 James Collins rated information technology it was astonishing

"Going Public" is much more than than a credobaptism vs. paedobaptism debate, although some of that argument is addressed. Information technology is an ecclesiological report of baptism and the Lord's Supper. Jamieson writes in a conversational way understandable by both the scholar and the layman. His Chapter 3 study of the theology of baptism is one of the best that I have ever read on the subject area, and should exist taught in all Baptist seminaries. If you take questions well-nigh baptism and how it functions in the church building, "Going Public" is much more than a credobaptism vs. paedobaptism debate, although some of that statement is addressed. It is an ecclesiological study of baptism and the Lord's Supper. Jamieson writes in a conversational fashion understandable past both the scholar and the layman. His Affiliate iii report of the theology of baptism is one of the best that I have ever read on the subject, and should be taught in all Baptist seminaries. If yous have questions virtually baptism and how information technology functions in the church, read this book. ...more than

The primary argument of Jamieson's book is that baptism is required for membership and for participation in the Lord's Supper. Jamieson argues that baptism and the Lord's Supper give the church a visible, institutional form and order. Baptism is the front door of the church, there's no other way in.

If you're unclear on if baptism should exist required for church membership, I'd recommend this book. For those interested in what baptism and the Lord Supper are, perchance pick upwards Jamieson'south smaller book

The primary argument of Jamieson's volume is that baptism is required for membership and for participation in the Lord'south Supper. Jamieson argues that baptism and the Lord's Supper give the church a visible, institutional class and guild. Baptism is the front door of the church, there's no other fashion in.

If you're unclear on if baptism should be required for church membership, I'd recommend this volume. For those interested in what baptism and the Lord Supper are, perhaps pick up Jamieson's smaller booklets, Understanding Baptism and Understanding the Lord's Supper.

...more than

December 27, 2017 Doug Connell rated it it was astonishing

Book Recommendation #seven

Very helpful and thorough arguments for explaining how the doctrine of baptism is revealed in the Scriptures and besides how it is connected to other doctrines such as the Gospel, conversion, church membership and subject field, and the Lord'due south Supper.

Jamieson interacts with contrary opinions - both from a historical and a gimmicky perspective; he also provides a very helpful affiliate: explaining why information technology matters in three minutes or less.

Book Recommendation #vii

Very helpful and thorough arguments for explaining how the doctrine of baptism is revealed in the Scriptures and also how it is continued to other doctrines such equally the Gospel, conversion, church membership and bailiwick, and the Lord's Supper.

Jamieson interacts with opposite opinions - both from a historical and a contemporary perspective; he also provides a very helpful affiliate: explaining why it matters in 3 minutes or less.

...more

Jan 02, 2021 Brett Wagner rated it really liked it

In this book, the author argues that baptism and the Lord'due south Supper are constructive signs of church building membership and that they create the social, ecclesial reality to which they point. Essentially, the volume not only argues for baptism being required for membership, but likewise an business relationship of how baptism and the Lord's Supper transform a scattered group of Christians into a gathered local church building (2).

A more often than not practiced and gospel centered approach to baptism. His tone was gracious simply some of his arguments and conclusions would autumn more on the realm of prudence than prescription. He consistently argues confronting paedobaptism on several fronts, however his covenant theology and insistence on agreement baptism through narrow covenant Al lenses almost makes the example for infant baptism.

Excellent defence force of Baptism equally necessary for church membership.

A must read for those who question baptism every bit a requirement of church membership. Jameson puts forrad an excellent defence for baptism as a requirement.

Aug 24, 2018 Jared rated it really liked it

Very thorough and helpful book. I agree with the vast bulk of where he lands, though some of the steps he takes forth the manner feel similar a bit of a stretch. Definitely a resource I'll come back to regularly. Very thorough and helpful book. I agree with the vast bulk of where he lands, though some of the steps he takes along the mode experience similar a bit of a stretch. Definitely a resource I'll come dorsum to regularly. ...more than

Mar 23, 2019 Rusty McMullen rated information technology actually liked it

Jamieson makes a Biblical argument for the necessity of baptism as a requirement for church membership. This piece of work was helpful in clarifying the arguments made for open and closed membership.

Mar 14, 2017 Levi Petro rated it really liked it

Baptism is a hard bailiwick to discuss within the church. The volume ties together baptism, membership, and the Lord'southward Supper extremely his arguments are sound and overall convincing. Overall, not the virtually compelling read but extremely helpful to those who'southward theology on these three ecclesiological practices may not be really cemented equally mine are. Highlights of the book, chapter 8 and the two capacity that were overcoming objections and going on the offensive. Baptism is a difficult subject to discuss within the church. The book ties together baptism, membership, and the Lord's Supper extremely his arguments are sound and overall convincing. Overall, not the most compelling read but extremely helpful to those who's theology on these iii ecclesiological practices may not be really cemented as mine are. Highlights of the volume, chapter eight and the two chapters that were overcoming objections and going on the offensive. ...more

Excellent Defense force of the Position

Great work on explaining and defending this position. Furthermore, fantabulous responses to other positions. May God use this volume mightily in local churches.

Mar 04, 2016 Seth Channell rated it actually liked it

If you don't have the fourth dimension to read the entire volume at least read chapter 8. So thankful this book was published. If you don't take the time to read the entire volume at least read chapter viii. So thankful this book was published. ...more

Oct 19, 2016 Erik Spohr rated it really liked it

Jamieson'southward "Going Public" packs a lot of content into 228 pages. Regardless of 1's stance on the issue of baptism, everyone will be edified past reading this work. Jamieson's "Going Public" packs a lot of content into 228 pages. Regardless of one'south opinion on the effect of baptism, everyone will be edified by reading this piece of work. ...more

Bobby Jamieson is a Ph.D. student in New Testament and affiliated lecturer in New Testament Greek at the University of Cambridge. He and his wife are members of Eden Baptist Church building, and they live in Cambridge with their 3 children. Bobby previously served as assistant editor for 9Marks.

See besides R.B. Jamieson

Bobby Jamieson is a Ph.D. student in New Testament and affiliated lecturer in New Testament Greek at the University of Cambridge. He and his married woman are members of Eden Baptist Church, and they live in Cambridge with their 3 children. Bobby previously served every bit assistant editor for 9Marks.

Run into also R.B. Jamieson

...more

News & Interviews

Need some other excuse to treat yourself to a new book this week? We've got y'all covered with the buzziest new releases of the day. To create our...

Welcome back. Simply a moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads account.

laboyimmill.blogspot.com

Source: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/23493020-going-public

Share this post